PTE Academic Write Essay · Discussion (both views and your opinion) · intermediate

Automation in Manufacturing: Balancing Efficiency and Employment

The prompt

Automation and robotics are replacing many manufacturing jobs that were traditionally done by human workers. Some believe this improves efficiency and safety, while others worry about widespread job losses. Discuss both views and give your opinion.

20 minutes. Write 200 to 300 words. A BandLadder practice prompt, not a recalled exam question.

Plan before you write

Position:
While automation undeniably enhances industrial productivity and safety, it necessitates proactive government intervention to mitigate the socio-economic impact of job displacement.
Paragraph 2:
The advantages of robotics in terms of operational efficiency and workplace safety.
Paragraph 3:
The challenges regarding structural unemployment and the ethical implications of workforce reduction.
  1. Give each view its own paragraph, explained fairly even where you disagree.
  2. Say where you stand in the introduction and again in the conclusion; the question asks for your opinion.
  3. Do not merge the two views into one paragraph; examiners look for both to be developed.

Sample essay

The integration of automation and robotics into the manufacturing sector has sparked a global debate regarding the future of human labour. While some argue that these technological advancements are essential for progress, others contend that they pose a significant threat to job security. This essay will examine both perspectives before arguing that while efficiency gains are vital, social safeguards are equally necessary.

Proponents of automation highlight the substantial improvements in industrial efficiency and safety. Robotic systems can operate continuously without fatigue, resulting in higher output levels and reduced error rates compared to manual labour. Furthermore, by delegating hazardous tasks, such as handling toxic chemicals or operating heavy machinery, to automated systems, companies can drastically lower the incidence of workplace injuries. For instance, the automotive industry has successfully utilised robotic assembly lines to enhance precision and protect workers from repetitive strain injuries.

Conversely, critics express concern over the widespread displacement of workers, particularly those in low-skilled positions. As machines become more sophisticated, the risk of structural unemployment increases, potentially widening the gap between different socioeconomic groups. If traditional manufacturing roles are eliminated faster than new, high-tech roles are created, many workers may find themselves obsolete. For example, the rapid digitisation of textile factories in developing economies has led to significant layoffs, leaving thousands of workers without a clear path to re-employment.

In conclusion, automation offers clear benefits in terms of productivity and safety, yet the potential for job loss remains a pressing concern. I believe that governments must implement comprehensive retraining programmes to facilitate the transition of the workforce into new sectors. By balancing technological adoption with human-centric policies, society can harness the benefits of robotics while ensuring economic stability for all citizens.

282 words. Use the structure and vocabulary, not the sentences: PTE flags memorised templates.

Why this scores well

This essay scores highly on linguistic range and coherence by employing complex sentence structures and logical transitions between contrasting viewpoints. A common error on this prompt is failing to provide a clear personal opinion or ignoring the 'discuss both views' requirement by focusing solely on one side.

Vocabulary from the essay

mitigate
to make something less severe or painful
operational efficiency
the ability to produce goods with minimal waste
structural unemployment
job loss caused by shifts in the economy
obsolete
no longer produced or used due to advancement
digitisation
the conversion of processes into digital systems
re-employment
the act of finding a new job
human-centric
designed with the primary focus on people
socioeconomic
relating to the interaction of social and economic factors

Write it yourself and get a PTE score

Answer this prompt in 20 minutes and get an AI score on the PTE essay traits, with the sentences that cost you marks.

Practise PTE Write Essay

See also the Write Essay guide.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a PTE essay be?

Between 200 and 300 words; outside that range the form score drops to zero. This sample is 282 words, written for the 20-minute limit.

What type of essay is this?

Discussion (both views and your opinion). Give each view its own paragraph, explained fairly even where you disagree.

What does PTE reward in the essay?

This essay scores highly on linguistic range and coherence by employing complex sentence structures and logical transitions between contrasting viewpoints. A common error on this prompt is failing to provide a clear personal opinion or ignoring the 'discuss both views' requirement by focusing solely on one side.

More work and careers essays