Global Moratorium on Gene Drive Technology Assessment
The prompt
Gene drives engineered through synthetic biology could theoretically eliminate disease-carrying mosquito populations, but releasing self-propagating genetic modifications into wild ecosystems raises unprecedented ecological and ethical questions. To what extent do you agree that gene drive technology should be subject to a global moratorium until comprehensive risk assessment frameworks are established?
20 minutes. Write 200 to 300 words. A BandLadder practice prompt, not a recalled exam question.
Plan before you write
- Position:
- I strongly agree that a global moratorium on gene drive implementation is essential to prevent irreversible ecological damage.
- Paragraph 2:
- The potential for unintended ecological disruption necessitates rigorous safety evaluations before any release.
- Paragraph 3:
- Ethical concerns regarding the manipulation of natural selection require international consensus and strict regulatory oversight.
- State a clear position in the last sentence of the introduction and keep it to the end.
- Two body paragraphs that each give one reason for that position, with an example.
- A partial position is fine if it is stated precisely; a position that drifts is what caps task response at 6.
Sample essay
The rapid advancement of synthetic biology has introduced gene drive technology, a powerful tool capable of eradicating disease-carrying vectors. While the potential to eliminate malaria is significant, the prospect of releasing self-propagating genetic modifications into the wild is alarming. I strongly agree that a global moratorium on this technology is necessary until comprehensive and transparent risk assessment frameworks are established.
Ecological systems are inherently complex and interdependent. Introducing genetically modified organisms that are designed to propagate indefinitely could trigger catastrophic, unforeseen consequences, such as the collapse of food webs or the emergence of invasive species. For instance, the elimination of a specific mosquito population might remove a critical food source for bats or fish, leading to a cascading decline in biodiversity. Without a global framework to evaluate these long-term environmental impacts, the risk of permanent damage to our biosphere is unacceptably high.
Furthermore, the ethical implications of altering the natural world demand international deliberation. Gene drives do not respect national boundaries, meaning a release in one country could permanently affect the genetic makeup of species in another. This creates a governance vacuum that individual nations cannot address alone. For example, the lack of a unified regulatory standard could lead to 'regulatory tourism,' where entities bypass safety protocols by operating in jurisdictions with weaker oversight. Establishing a moratorium ensures that global ethical standards and accountability mechanisms are in place before such transformative power is unleashed.
In conclusion, while gene drives offer promising solutions for public health, the risks to global ecosystems and the lack of ethical oversight necessitate a pause. A global moratorium is the only responsible path forward to ensure that innovation does not compromise the stability of our natural world.
281 words. Use the structure and vocabulary, not the sentences: PTE flags memorised templates.
Why this scores well
This essay scores highly on linguistic range and development, using precise vocabulary and logical transitions between complex arguments. The most common mistake on this prompt is failing to address the 'global' aspect of the moratorium, focusing only on the scientific risk rather than the necessity for international cooperation.
Vocabulary from the essay
- Interdependent
- dependent on each other for survival or function
- Cascading
- occurring in a series of linked sequential events
- Biosphere
- the regions of the earth occupied by life
- Deliberation
- long and careful consideration of a complex matter
- Governance
- the action or manner of regulating an activity
- Regulatory
- concerned with the enforcement of rules and laws
- Transformative
- causing a marked change in someone or something
- Unforeseen
- not anticipated or predicted before it happens
Write it yourself and get a PTE score
Answer this prompt in 20 minutes and get an AI score on the PTE essay traits, with the sentences that cost you marks.
Practise PTE Write EssaySee also the Write Essay guide.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a PTE essay be?
Between 200 and 300 words; outside that range the form score drops to zero. This sample is 281 words, written for the 20-minute limit.
What type of essay is this?
Opinion (agree or disagree). State a clear position in the last sentence of the introduction and keep it to the end.
What does PTE reward in the essay?
This essay scores highly on linguistic range and development, using precise vocabulary and logical transitions between complex arguments. The most common mistake on this prompt is failing to address the 'global' aspect of the moratorium, focusing only on the scientific risk rather than the necessity for international cooperation.
More science and research essays
- Addressing Challenges of Plan S Open Access Mandates
- Addressing Complex Challenges in Modern Space Exploration
- Addressing Complex Challenges of Modern Scientific Innovation
- Addressing Systemic Challenges in Scientific Innovation
- Addressing the Escalating Costs of Space Exploration
- Addressing the Uncertainties of Nanoplastic Toxicity Research
- All 445 PTE essay samples