Ethical Implications and Benefits of Posthuman Biotechnology
The prompt
Advances in biotechnology such as gene editing, synthetic biology, and human-animal chimera research challenge traditional ethical frameworks grounded in notions of natural human identity. Discuss both the ethical objections to and the potential benefits of posthuman biotechnological interventions.
20 minutes. Write 200 to 300 words. A BandLadder practice prompt, not a recalled exam question.
Plan before you write
- Position:
- While posthuman biotechnologies present significant ethical dilemmas regarding identity, their potential to eradicate suffering and extend human capacity justifies their careful advancement.
- Paragraph 2:
- Ethical concerns regarding the disruption of natural human identity and the risk of irreversible genetic consequences.
- Paragraph 3:
- The transformative medical benefits of gene editing and synthetic biology in treating terminal illnesses.
- Give each view its own paragraph, explained fairly even where you disagree.
- Say where you stand in the introduction and again in the conclusion; the question asks for your opinion.
- Do not merge the two views into one paragraph; examiners look for both to be developed.
Sample essay
Rapid advancements in biotechnology, including gene editing and synthetic biology, have initiated a profound debate regarding the boundaries of human nature. While these innovations promise unprecedented medical breakthroughs, they simultaneously challenge traditional ethical frameworks that define human identity. This essay will examine the moral objections to such interventions while highlighting their potential to revolutionize human health.
Critics of posthuman research argue that manipulating the human genome risks violating the integrity of the species. The primary ethical concern is the potential for irreversible biological consequences, as altering genetic pathways could produce unforeseen mutations or exacerbate social inequalities. For instance, the prospect of 'designer babies' raises fears of a new form of eugenics, where genetic enhancement becomes a luxury for the elite, thereby fundamentally altering the trajectory of human evolution and social equity.
Conversely, the potential benefits of these biotechnological interventions are substantial, particularly in addressing previously incurable conditions. Gene editing technologies, such as CRISPR, offer the possibility of correcting hereditary disorders at the molecular level, potentially eradicating debilitating diseases. For example, clinical trials targeting sickle cell anaemia have demonstrated the capacity for synthetic interventions to transform lives, suggesting that the moral imperative to alleviate human suffering should take precedence over static definitions of natural identity.
In conclusion, although the development of posthuman technologies necessitates rigorous ethical oversight to prevent misuse, the therapeutic advantages remain compelling. By balancing caution with innovation, society can harness these scientific tools to enhance human well-being. Ultimately, the evolution of our species through technology is an inevitable progression that, if managed responsibly, will lead to a more resilient and healthy global population.
265 words. Use the structure and vocabulary, not the sentences: PTE flags memorised templates.
Why this scores well
This essay scores highly on linguistic range and vocabulary by employing sophisticated terminology to discuss abstract ethical concepts. The most common error on this prompt is failing to provide specific examples, leading to vague arguments that lack development.
Vocabulary from the essay
- posthuman
- Relating to a future state beyond current human limitations
- eugenics
- The practice of improving the genetic quality of humans
- imperative
- A vital or urgent requirement for action
- debilitating
- Causing someone to become very weak or infirm
- trajectory
- The path or direction of a development process
- molecular
- Relating to the smallest unit of chemical substances
- unprecedented
- Never done or known to have occurred before
- resilient
- Able to withstand or recover from difficult conditions
Write it yourself and get a PTE score
Answer this prompt in 20 minutes and get an AI score on the PTE essay traits, with the sentences that cost you marks.
Practise PTE Write EssaySee also the Write Essay guide.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a PTE essay be?
Between 200 and 300 words; outside that range the form score drops to zero. This sample is 265 words, written for the 20-minute limit.
What type of essay is this?
Discussion (both views and your opinion). Give each view its own paragraph, explained fairly even where you disagree.
What does PTE reward in the essay?
This essay scores highly on linguistic range and vocabulary by employing sophisticated terminology to discuss abstract ethical concepts. The most common error on this prompt is failing to provide specific examples, leading to vague arguments that lack development.
More science and research essays
- Addressing Challenges of Plan S Open Access Mandates
- Addressing Complex Challenges in Modern Space Exploration
- Addressing Complex Challenges of Modern Scientific Innovation
- Addressing Systemic Challenges in Scientific Innovation
- Addressing the Escalating Costs of Space Exploration
- Addressing the Uncertainties of Nanoplastic Toxicity Research
- All 445 PTE essay samples