Many modern devices, from smartphones to washing machines, are built in ways that make repairs difficult or uneconomical, so consumers often have little choice but to buy a replacement. I strongly agree that manufacturers should be legally obliged to design products that can be repaired easily, for both environmental and economic reasons.
The first argument concerns waste. When a phone with a failing battery cannot be opened without special tools, or a washing machine needs an entire control unit replaced for one faulty component, the whole device is often thrown away. Electronic waste contains valuable metals and harmful substances, and much of it is not recycled properly. Every product discarded early also represents the energy and raw materials used to manufacture it. If a battery could be replaced in a few minutes, many phones would remain in use for several more years.
The second argument is that voluntary change by industry is unlikely. Manufacturers earn more when customers buy new products, so they have little commercial incentive to make repairs simple or to sell spare parts at reasonable prices. Some even restrict independent repair shops by refusing to supply them with components or manuals. Only legal requirements, such as rules that spare parts must be available for a fixed number of years and that devices must be opened with ordinary tools, can create a level playing field. Consumers would benefit financially, and local repair businesses would gain work.
Some critics claim that such rules could raise prices or limit design, for example by making phones slightly thicker. However, these costs seem minor compared with the waste and expense of constant replacement. In my view, therefore, a legal right to repair is a sensible and overdue measure.