In a number of countries, schools are placed in league tables according to how well their students perform in national examinations. Some people argue that these rankings help parents and drive up standards, whereas others believe they are harmful. In my opinion, tables based purely on exam results do more harm than good, even though parents are entitled to some information about schools.
Supporters of league tables make two main arguments. Firstly, choosing a school is one of the most important decisions parents make, and published results offer a clear, comparable measure of performance. Without them, families might rely on rumour or reputation. Secondly, public rankings create accountability. A school that appears near the bottom of the table faces pressure from parents and local authorities to improve its teaching, which, in principle, benefits its students.
However, raw exam results often say more about a school's intake than about the quality of its teaching. A selective school in a wealthy area will usually top the rankings, even if its teachers add relatively little, while a school serving a disadvantaged community may do remarkable work and still appear to be failing. This can discourage good teachers from working where they are most needed. Furthermore, the pressure to climb the table encourages schools to narrow the curriculum, focusing on exam technique and dropping subjects such as music or drama that do not count towards the rankings.
Overall, I believe that simple league tables give a misleading picture and distort what schools teach. A fairer approach would be to publish measures of the progress students make from the point they join a school, together with inspection reports, so that parents receive useful information without schools being judged mainly on the backgrounds of their pupils.