Opinions differ on how best to respond to climate change. Some people see mass tree planting as the most effective solution, whereas others insist that cutting our use of fossil fuels matters far more. Although trees have an important role to play, I believe that reducing fossil fuel consumption must come first.
Advocates of tree planting point out that forests naturally absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it for many years. Planting schemes are relatively cheap, easy to understand and popular with the public, which makes them politically attractive. They also bring additional benefits: new woodland provides habitats for wildlife, reduces the risk of flooding by holding water in the soil, and offers people green spaces for recreation. A company that funds the planting of thousands of trees can show a visible, positive contribution in a way that is harder to achieve with less tangible measures.
However, those who prioritise cutting emissions argue convincingly that trees cannot keep pace with the amount of carbon released by burning coal, oil and gas. A young tree absorbs very little carbon in its first years and may take decades to reach its full capacity, while emissions from power stations and vehicles continue every day. Moreover, the carbon stored in forests is not permanent, since trees can be destroyed by wildfires or cut down for land. There is also a danger that planting schemes allow polluting industries to appear environmentally responsible while making no real changes to how they operate.
In my view, tree planting is a useful supplement rather than a substitute for reducing fossil fuel use. Governments should concentrate on expanding renewable energy and cleaner transport, while protecting existing forests and planting new ones as an additional measure.