Many governments provide free lunches to schoolchildren, but there is disagreement about who should receive them. Some people believe every pupil should be entitled to a free meal, while others argue that this support should be limited to children from low-income households. Although targeting has clear financial advantages, I believe that providing free meals for all pupils, at least in primary schools, is the better policy.
Those who prefer a targeted approach argue that public money should be directed where the need is greatest. Feeding every child, including those whose parents could easily pay, costs a great deal, and the same budget could fund more teachers or better buildings. In their view, a well-paid lawyer's son does not need a subsidised lunch, and offering one is simply an inefficient use of taxpayers' money. They also note that most families on average incomes can easily prepare a packed lunch.
However, there are strong arguments for a universal scheme. When only poorer children receive free meals, they can be easily identified by classmates, and the resulting stigma leads some families not to claim the meals they are entitled to. Means-tested schemes also miss many children just above the income threshold, such as those whose parents work long hours in low-paid jobs and still struggle to buy nutritious food. If every pupil eats the same lunch together, no child is singled out, and teachers often notice that pupils concentrate better in afternoon lessons.
In conclusion, although limiting free meals to the poorest families would save money, I believe universal provision is fairer and more effective, because it reaches every child who needs it without making anyone feel ashamed of their family's circumstances.