In some countries, school leavers are obliged to spend a period in the armed forces before beginning work or higher education. Supporters believe this builds discipline and national unity, but I largely disagree that it should be compulsory for every young person, as it is an inefficient use of resources and forces people into a role that may not suit them.
The main drawback is cost and inefficiency. Modern armed forces rely on highly trained specialists who operate complex equipment, and a recruit who serves for only twelve months will have barely completed basic training before leaving. Feeding, housing and training an entire age group each year would therefore consume a large share of the defence budget while adding little real capability. That money could achieve far more if spent on a smaller, professional force or on public services such as schools and hospitals.
A further objection is that compulsion ignores individual circumstances and beliefs. A young woman who has won a place to study medicine would see her career delayed by a year, while a pacifist might be required to handle weapons against his conscience. Many of the qualities that military service is said to develop, such as teamwork, self-reliance and respect for others, can be gained equally well through apprenticeships, sport or voluntary projects that young people choose for themselves.
Admittedly, countries facing a direct military threat may have little choice but to train large numbers of citizens. In most cases, however, I believe military service should remain voluntary, with governments encouraging young people to contribute to society through a range of options rather than obliging them all to join the armed forces.