Writing Task 2 · Discussion (both views)

Punishing parents for children's crimes: IELTS Writing Task 2 sample answer

An IELTS Writing Task 2 discussion essay question with a Band 8-style sample answer, the plan behind it, the vocabulary that lifts it and what an examiner looks for.
  • 277 words
  • Discussion (both views)
  • Academic
  • 40 minutes

The question

Some people think that parents should be legally punished when their children commit crimes, while others believe that young offenders alone should be held responsible. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.

About 40 minutes. Write at least 250 words.

Discussion (both views)

Plan before you write

  1. 1

    Your position

    The young person should normally be responsible, but parents can be penalised for clear, repeated neglect.

  2. 2

    Paragraph 2

    Supporters say behaviour is shaped at home and penalties would push careless parents to supervise better.

  3. 3

    Paragraph 3

    Opponents say it is unjust to punish adults for acts they did not commit, and it can hurt struggling families.

  • →Explain both views fairly, with reasons or examples for each.
  • →If the prompt asks for your opinion, state it clearly and support it throughout the response.
  • →A separate paragraph for each view can help organise the discussion; make the relationship between the views clear.

Model answer

Band 8-style sample essay

This AI-generated teaching example illustrates target features; it has not received an official IELTS band. Compare its ideas and structure with your own response.

Band 8-style model277 words · use the structure and vocabulary, not the sentences

When a child or teenager breaks the law, there is often debate about who should bear the consequences. Some argue that parents should face legal penalties for their children's offences, while others believe responsibility lies with the young offender. In my view, parents should be penalised only when there is clear evidence of serious neglect, not simply because their child has committed a crime.

Those who favour punishing parents point out that children's behaviour is shaped largely at home. A parent who allows a fourteen-year-old to stay out all night, never asks where they have been and ignores repeated warnings from school has arguably contributed to any vandalism or theft that follows. Fining such parents or requiring them to attend parenting courses could encourage closer supervision, and supporters argue that the threat of a penalty would make negligent families take their duties more seriously.

On the other hand, many people feel it is unjust to punish adults for actions they did not commit. Teenagers are increasingly independent, and even conscientious parents cannot monitor them every hour of the day; a mother working night shifts to support her family may have no idea that her son has joined a gang. Penalising her would add financial strain to a household that is already struggling, which could make the child's situation worse rather than better.

Overall, I believe the young person should normally be held responsible, in a way that reflects their age. However, where parents have clearly and repeatedly failed to supervise their children, courts should be able to impose measures such as compulsory parenting programmes, since this targets genuine negligence without punishing families who have done their best.

Model commentary

Features to notice in this model

This essay aims to illustrate Band 8 features: both views are explained fairly with their own examples, and the writer's opinion is stated in the introduction and refined in the conclusion with a clear condition about neglect. A Band 6 answer to this question often presents the two views as short lists and gives an opinion only in the final line, or confuses legal punishment with ordinary parental discipline.

Now write it yourself, against the clock

Forty minutes, then paste your essay into the free writing checker: a band for task response, coherence, vocabulary and grammar from BandLadder AI, with every mistake marked. Try AI feedback before signup.

Check my essay free →

8 words

Vocabulary from the essay

  • bear the consequences

    accept the results of something, usually bad ones

  • penalised

    given a punishment, such as a fine

  • neglect

    failure to give proper care or attention

  • supervision

    watching someone to make sure they behave well

  • negligent

    not taking enough care over a duty

  • conscientious

    careful and serious about doing things properly

  • financial strain

    pressure caused by not having enough money

  • impose

    officially force a rule or punishment on someone

More words for this topic: IELTS vocabulary for government, law and crime.

Frequently asked questions

What type of essay is "Punishing parents for children's crimes"?+

Discussion (both views). Explain both views fairly, with reasons or examples for each.

How many words should an IELTS Writing Task 2 essay be?+

At least 250 words, in about 40 minutes. This sample is 277 words, written to fit that time with five minutes left to check grammar.

How is IELTS Writing Task 2 scored?+

On four criteria: task response, coherence and cohesion, vocabulary, and grammatical range and accuracy. Task 2 counts for twice as much as Task 1 in your Writing band.

What is the difference between a Band 6 and a Band 8 answer here?+

This essay aims to illustrate Band 8 features: both views are explained fairly with their own examples, and the writer's opinion is stated in the introduction and refined in the conclusion with a clear condition about neglect. A Band 6 answer to this question often presents the two views as short lists and gives an opinion only in the final line, or confuses legal punishment with ordinary parental discipline.

Keep practising

More sample essays

© 2026 BandLadder. Written and checked by the BandLadder team. You may quote or cite this page with credit to BandLadder and a link to it; republishing it in full needs our written permission. Content use policy