Several private companies now sell brief flights to the edge of space to customers who can afford tickets costing many times the average annual salary. Some people welcome this as an exciting advance, whereas others regard it as a wasteful and polluting luxury. In my view, although space tourism may bring some technological benefits, it is largely difficult to justify at present.
Those who support space tourism argue that it drives innovation. When wealthy customers pay for flights, private companies gain funds to develop new technology, such as reusable rockets, which can make launching satellites and scientific equipment cheaper for everyone. Supporters also point out that the money comes from private individuals rather than taxpayers, so it does not take resources from public services. In addition, they claim that seeing the Earth from space can inspire passengers, and the public, to value the planet and to take an interest in science.
Critics, however, emphasise the environmental and ethical costs. A single rocket launch burns a large quantity of fuel to carry a handful of passengers for a few minutes of weightlessness, so the emissions per person are far higher than those of an ordinary flight. At a time when governments are asking citizens to reduce their own carbon footprint by driving or flying less, the sight of billionaires taking joyrides into space sends a damaging message. Critics also argue that the engineering talent involved could be devoted to more pressing problems on Earth, such as clean energy.
On balance, I agree with the critics. Space research is valuable, but tourist flights for the very rich contribute little to it compared with their environmental impact. Until rockets become far cleaner, such trips should at least be taxed heavily to reflect the pollution they cause.